Add all ingredients for blood orange vinaigrette to a mason jar, tightly seal lid and shake until fully combined (or you can just whisk it together).: The vinaigrette should smell bright and citrus forward, with the sweet grain of maple syrup lifting the blood orange and lemon juice notes. After shaking or whisking, you want a slightly glossy emulsion where the olive oil has suspended the juices, not a separated pool of oil on top. This emulsion helps the dressing cling to the kale , ensuring each leaf gets flavor without becoming soggy. If the dressing separates after sitting, give it another vigorous shake, and when whisking, try a fork or small whisk for better incorporation. A common mistake is using cold oil and cold juice at markedly different temperatures, which can make emulsification slower; let ingredients sit at room temperature for a few minutes if needed.
Add the torn kale to a large salad bowl. Pour a few tablespoons of the dressing over the kale, then massage the dressing into the kale for a few minutes. Allow to sit while preparing the rest of the ingredients.: You should hear a slight rustle as the torn kale hits the bowl, and the leaves will look matte and dense before dressing. Kneading warmth from your hands into the leaves softens them and releases a faintly earthy aroma. Because kale is sturdy, it benefits from physical treatment so the fibers relax and become more palatable. A common misstep is skipping this step, which leaves the leaves tough and makes the salad less enjoyable.
To assemble salad, add the rest of the salad ingredients to the salad bowl, toss to combine. Top with more dressing or serve with dressing on the side.: As you work the dressing into the kale , you will feel the texture change from rigid to supple, and the color will deepen into a glossier, darker green as the leaves absorb the dressing. Massaging breaks down cell walls and allows the citrus and salt to mellow the vegetal bitterness, creating a pleasant chew. Stop once the leaves are pliable but still have body. Over massaging can make the leaves limp and watery, so aim for tenderness not dissolution. If the salad tastes flat after massaging, it usually needs a pinch more salt to lift the flavors.
Allow to sit while preparing the rest of the ingredients: Letting the dressed kale rest for a few minutes allows the flavors to marry, and the texture to soften slightly in a way that enhances mouthfeel. During this time, prepare the persimmon and mandarin orange so they are ready to add, and crumble the goat cheese for even distribution. Resist the urge to assemble immediately because the short rest yields a more cohesive salad. A typical error is waiting too long and letting the leaves sit in too much dressing, which can make them soggy, so keep an eye on timing.
To assemble salad, add the rest of the salad ingredients to the salad bowl, toss to combine: As you add the persimmon , mandarin orange , goat cheese , walnuts , and cooked chicken to the dressed kale , notice the contrast of colors and textures; the shiny citrus segments, the pale soft cheese, and the deep green leaves should create a visually appealing mix. Toss gently so you don’t crush the fruit segments, and use a folding motion to distribute ingredients evenly. This gentle toss helps the dressing adhere without bruising delicate pieces. A common mistake is tossing too roughly, which can break fruit wedges and make the salad look and taste messy.
Top with more dressing or serve with dressing on the side: Taste the assembled salad and decide if it needs more of the vinaigrette for brightness or a touch more salt and pepper to finish. Serving extra dressing on the side lets people control how dressed they want their salad, which is helpful if you plan to serve this at a crowd event. If you add more dressing, pour sparingly and toss again to avoid overdressing and weighing down the kale . A usual slip up is adding too much dressing at once; it is easier to add than remove, so go slowly.