Preheat Air Fryer to 390 degrees Fahrenheit.: When you preheat, the machine reaches an even cooking temperature which jump starts the browning process. You should hear a faint hum as the fan circulates air, and after a few minutes the basket will feel warm to the touch when you bring your hand close, not touching the surfaces. This immediate hot environment ensures the outside of each cube begins to crisp quickly, sealing in moisture so the interior stays tender. A common mistake is skipping preheat, which leads to uneven color and longer cook times; always allow a couple of minutes of preheating so the oil sizzles on contact.
Wash and peel sweet potatoes. Dice into 1'' cubes and put into a mixing bowl.: Clean, dry sweet potatoes are essential for even roasting. After peeling, aim for uniform one inch cubes so each piece cooks at the same rate, producing consistent texture across the batch. As you dice, notice the scent of raw sweet potatoes , a faint earthy sweetness, and the slightly moist sheen on each cut face. If pieces vary dramatically in size, the smaller bits will overcook and the larger will remain firm. To avoid this, take your time cutting and trim any very small fragments off so all cubes are similar.
Add the rest of ingredients and toss to coat.: Once the cubes are in a bowl, pour in the olive oil , sprinkle the garlic salt , smoked paprika , and ground pepper , then toss until every cube has a light sheen. Proper coating encourages even browning and distributes flavor; you should see a pale orange glaze on each piece from the oil and paprika. The tactile feel should be slick but not dripping. Overcrowding in the bowl during tossing can lead to uneven seasoning, so give the cubes space to move or toss in batches if needed.
Place in preheated Air Fryer.: Arrange the seasoned cubes in a single layer in the basket, leaving tiny gaps between pieces so hot air can circulate. When you place them in, you may hear a soft sizzle as the hot air meets the oiled surfaces, a good sign the crisping process has begun. Visually, the oil should begin to shimmer slightly within the first minute. If you pile them, steam will build and rob the exterior of crispness, so keep the layer thin and consider cooking in two batches for very full portions.
Cook for 10 minutes, toss sweet potatoes and cook an additional 4 minutes or until roasted and cooked through.: During the initial cooking, expect the aroma to shift from raw starch to warm, caramelly notes. After about 10 minutes the edges should show golden-brown caramelization. Tossing is important to expose all sides to the heat, promoting even color and texture. After the second phase, the cubes should display a mix of deep amber edges and tender, yielding centers. If they still feel firm when pierced, give them a couple more minutes. A common error is under tossing, which creates uneven browning; be deliberate and use tongs to flip and redistribute pieces.
Serve immediately.: Right out of the basket the cubes will have the crispiest exterior and warm, creamy interior. Serve while hot for the best contrast, and notice how the crust crackles faintly when you bite into it, releasing a burst of sweet, smoky flavor. If you wait too long, steam will soften the exterior, so transfer promptly to a warmed dish and enjoy without delay. Reheating later will be fine, but it will not perfectly match the initial crispness.